Arkansas was the primary state to begin sending letters house flagging college students’ Physique Mass Index. Twenty years later, they don’t seem to have had any impact on childhood weight problems.
AYESHA RASCOE, HOST:
Greater than 20 years in the past, public faculties in Arkansas started measuring college students’ peak and weight. Then they ship letters house with the kid’s physique mass index as a part of an effort to cut back childhood weight problems. Not less than 23 states have adopted comparable practices. Kavitha Cardoza reviews the letters apparently have had no impression on weight reduction and might have unintended penalties.
KAVITHA CARDOZA, BYLINE: Sixth-grade boys joke round as they line as much as be measured. All wish to be the tallest.
UNIDENTIFIED STUDENT #1: Simply, like, a benefit. You possibly can play, like, basketball.
UNIDENTIFIED STUDENT #2: A taller dude can get extra ladies since you’re tall.
(LAUGHTER)
UNIDENTIFIED STUDENT #2: Shut up, guys. Shut up.
CARDOZA: Anndrea Veasley, the registered nurse at Mann Arts and Science Magnet Center College in Little Rock, has the 11-year-olds come up individually. One boy slouches.
ANNDREA VEASLEY: Arise straight for me.
CARDOZA: Subsequent, Veasley asks him to step on a digital scale however backward so he cannot see the numbers. She silently notes his measurements – 4’7″ and 115.6 kilos.
VEASLEY: You’re good to go. You wish to put your sneakers on.
CARDOZA: This kid’s dad and mom are amongst 1000’s who obtain a letter with their kid’s physique mass index, or BMI, calculated. We’re not utilizing youngsters’s names due to the stigma and bullying related to weight problems. This BMI quantity additionally categorizes every little one as regular, obese or overweight.
JOE THOMPSON: This isn’t a shaming effort.
CARDOZA: That is Dr. Joe Thompson, who leads the Arkansas Middle for Well being Enchancment. He is the pediatrician who helped create this system again in 2003. However since then, the state’s childhood weight problems charges have risen from 21- to 24%. A number of research have proven that these fats letters, as they’re typically mockingly known as, have had no impact on weight reduction.
THOMPSON: I do not suppose it was ever meant to be a singular magic bullet. This was simply elevating ranges of consciousness.
CARDOZA: Thompson says these letters might help warn dad and mom if their little one is vulnerable to creating critical well being points. Arkansas now measures all public faculty college students in even grades yearly, apart from seniors. That is as a result of they’ve nearly graduated but additionally due to what Thompson calls their shenanigans.
THOMPSON: We had one faculty the place lots of the boys got here in with leg weights on beneath their denims. And after we went to investigate the info, we noticed that clearly one thing was not proper.
CARDOZA: Some specialists have criticized the letters, saying they’ll result in weight stigma and consuming issues.
KIMBERLY COLLINS: I am making blackened salmon and rice and asparagus.
(SOUNDBITE OF GAS STOVE LIGHTING)
CARDOZA: Kimberly Collins has 4 youngsters. She’s acquired BMI letters yearly flagging them as obese. One in every of them, Lynn, is taken into account overweight. Lynn says strangers typically stare at her and cross feedback.
LYNN COLLINS: On my birthday final yr, I went to – needed to get my allergy photographs, and one of many nurses advised me, you’re getting chubbier, and that did not make me really feel the very best.
CARDOZA: Mother Kimberly says studying the letters offended her.
COLLINS: ‘Trigger it made me really feel like I wasn’t doing my job as a mother. I felt judged. Although it was not a blaming letter, it nonetheless felt that means.
CARDOZA: Collins already adopted the really helpful wholesome practices for her youngsters, like a number of vegetables and fruit and after-school sports activities. She even signed up for diet lessons.
COLLINS: However even that is not sufficient to fight the problem that we’re having.
CARDOZA: In contrast to the Collins household, research present few dad and mom observe up with a well being care supplier or make modifications. Hannah Thompson, a College of California Berkeley assistant professor, has studied BMI letters. She says, the large downside – most dad and mom do not even keep in mind getting one.
HANNAH THOMPSON: It is so low contact, it is actually not very efficient.
CARDOZA: A fair greater downside is what to do with the data.
THOMPSON: You discover out your little one is asthmatic, and you may get an inhaler, proper? You discover out that your little one is obese – what do you do?
CARDOZA: Collins says it is painful to see her soft-spoken and sort daughter Lynn, who’s now 15, cowl herself along with her arms as if she’s making an attempt to cover. {The teenager} has begun sneaking meals.
COLLINS: She will not flip the sunshine on within the lavatory.
CARDOZA: She would not wish to take a look at herself within the mirror.
COLLINS: She would not. And if I flip the sunshine on within the lavatory, she yells at me.
CARDOZA: Some states have scaled again on BMI reporting. One faculty district in Wyoming used to incorporate the numbers in report playing cards. They’ve stopped. Even Arkansas modified its guidelines to permit dad and mom to choose out. For NPR, I am Kavitha Cardoza.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional data.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content might not be in its ultimate kind and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability could differ. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.
